Using compost after you read a soil test

Last updated

When a soil test says to skip compost, how to read a compost analysis for phosphorus, salts, and carbon-to-nitrogen ratio, and when to retest.

Compost is a soil amendment with a fertilizer analysis, not a neutral brown mulch. The New England Vegetable Management Guide says finished compost is typically about a 1-1-1 grade (N, P2O5, K2O) and that the real analysis swings widely with the feedstocks and the process. The guide’s instruction is to test the compost for available nitrogen, total nitrogen, P2O5, and K2O before you spread it on a field, and to test the soil as well. University of Minnesota Extension says the same pairing in the other order: any time you add compost, test the soil first, and if you buy in bulk, ask the seller for a compost analysis. A pile that looks finished can still be the wrong addition once the soil report is in hand.

If phosphorus is already high, the compost stays in the pile

UMass Amherst’s soil lab says high nutrient results in New England gardens and small farms commonly trace to over-fertilization or to heavy use of compost, manure, and other organic materials. Phosphorus is the nutrient that tends to stay, because it binds to soil particles and does not leach the way nitrogen does. The exception the lab flags is very high phosphorus near water, where it can still reach waterways, feed algae, and kill fish. The lab’s management list is direct: test before you apply fertilizer or any nutrient source, including compost. If the plants look healthy, do not add fertilizer or organic amendments, compost included, and test again at the end of the season. If the plants look poor, still do not add those materials until you know whether salts are the problem. Keep testing yearly until the numbers fall. UMass says levels come down by crop removal and weathering, and that waiting is sometimes the right management. In New England, a high pH also drifts down over time without an amendment.

The New England guide is just as plain when it comes to the cutoff. Extra compost on soil that already tests optimum for phosphorus can push the test above optimum. If the soil test is already above optimum, avoid compost until phosphorus returns to the optimum range. The guide’s table of maximum rates goes to “no application” in the above-optimum column for low-, medium-, and high-phosphorus composts alike. On optimum soil, a high-phosphorus compost (about 1.5 to 3.0 percent P2O5 on a dry-weight basis) is also a “no application,” while a medium compost (0.5 to 1.5 percent) is limited to about 5 tons per acre and a low one (0.1 to 0.5 percent) to about 30 tons per acre. Those tonnages assume about 45 percent moisture and are written for the guide’s soil-test categories. They are not a backyard scoop count. They do show the pattern: the richer the compost is in phosphorus, and the higher the soil test already is, the smaller the allowed addition, down to zero.

The few studies the guide cites found that composts made mostly from manure supplied phosphorus through the season at roughly 70 to 100 percent of the availability of triple superphosphate. This is why a “low analysis” compost can still load a bed. If you apply the guide’s rates every year, retest extractable phosphorus annually so you notice the climb.

University of Minnesota’s compost-interpretation page tells gardeners to plan as if all of the total phosphorus in the compost will become available. That assumption is deliberately cautious: it keeps soil-test phosphorus from creeping up. The lab reports total phosphorus as a percent of dry weight, so you need the moisture before you can turn the percent into a spreading rate. Other labs report parts per million, which is the same as milligrams per kilogram. UMN’s conversion is: divide ppm by 10,000 to get percent phosphorus, divide by 100 to get pounds of phosphorus per pound of dry compost, then multiply by 2.3 to express it as P2O5. Their example uses a report of 28,400 ppm phosphorus, which is 2.84 percent on a dry basis, or about 0.065 pounds of P2O5 per pound of dry compost. At 50 percent moisture that falls to about 0.033 pounds of P2O5 per pound of fresh compost. If a cubic yard of that fresh compost weighs 1,000 pounds, the yard carries about 33 pounds of P2O5. The page notes that a cubic yard may weigh anywhere from about 800 to 1,500 pounds depending on moisture, and that weighing a cubic foot of your own pile is the honest way to scale it. Do not copy the 1,000-pound assumption onto a wet municipal compost without a scale.

Potassium in finished compost is more available than the nitrogen, because it is not locked inside organic compounds. The New England guide notes that some of it leaches: one study saw potassium drop about 25 percent when finished compost sat uncovered outdoors through a winter. UMN treats essentially all of the potassium as available at spreading time and converts ppm to K2O with a factor of 1.2, after the same percent-and-moisture steps used for phosphorus.

Carbon-to-nitrogen ratios are not one shared target

Here the two references disagree, and the disagreement matters.

The New England guide says the recommended carbon-to-nitrogen ratio for finished compost is 15:1 to 18:1. Its table lists finished compost around 17:1 to 20:1, cow manure around 18:1, agricultural soils around 8:1 to 14:1, oat straw at 70:1, rye straw at 82:1, and hardwood sawdust at 500:1. If the ratio of an organic material is much above 30:1, microbes immobilize soil nitrogen until they work through the carbon. That nitrogen is tied up, not gone, but the crop cannot use it in the meantime.

UMN’s compost page calls an ideal compost ratio about 25:1 to 30:1. Above that, microbes immobilize plant-available nitrogen, which may not be released in time for the crop. A lower ratio breaks down faster and leaves nitrogen over, which can be lost if no roots are there to take it up. Ratios vary a lot by source.

Do not average these into a single “best” number. Ask which range the lab that tested your compost uses, and read the ratio next to that lab’s note. A 28:1 result can be inside UMN’s window and well above the New England finished-compost window. The practical shared warning is the high-carbon end: strawy, woody, unfinished material will compete with the crop for nitrogen. The New England guide says most of the nitrogen in finished compost, usually over 90 percent, is in organic compounds that resist decay, and that only about 10 to 30 percent of that nitrogen becomes available in the first season. Later years release more, more slowly. Repeated heavy use, above 400 pounds of nitrogen per acre per year from compost, can leave excess nitrate in the soil.

UMN describes the same split with different first-year math, and labels it as an example: compost nitrogen might be 70 percent available the first year and about 5 percent the second. Use the credit your own lab prints. Stacking a full fertilizer rate on top of an uncounted compost credit is how beds end up with more nitrogen than the crop can use. UMN notes that too much nitrogen pushes vegetative growth and, for some crops, can cut yield.

Salts are a container problem first

The New England guide says soluble salts are usually not a problem when compost is mixed into field soil, because 40 tons per acre worked into the top 6 inches is about one part compost to 50 parts soil. In a greenhouse mix the compost is a much larger share of the volume, so salts matter. Compost headed for a greenhouse medium should test under 1 mmho per centimeter electrical conductivity, and it should be tested for maturity as well. Submit it as a compost sample. A field-soil method on a compost bag gives numbers the lab did not calibrate.

UMN reports conductivity on a saturated-paste extract, in millimhos per centimeter. Those units match decisiemens per meter and millisiemens per centimeter. A 1:1 or 1:2 dilution from another lab cannot be lined up against a saturated-paste number. UMN’s paste-extract scale runs from 0 to 2 mmhos/cm (non-saline, no crop effect) through 2.1 to 4 (sensitive crops restricted), 4.1 to 8 (many crops restricted), 8.1 to 16 (most crops restricted), and above 16 (few plants tolerant). On the crop table tied to that scale, blueberries, carrots, green beans, onions, radishes, raspberries, and strawberries sit in the nontolerant group, while asparagus and Swiss chard are the tolerant examples. High-salt compost needs caution in raised beds, high tunnels, and any place you add a large amount in spring, because germination can stall and plants stress, and because tunnels and covered beds do not get the rain that would flush salts. UMN’s options are to blend the compost with soil to dilute it, or to leave it outside for a season so rain can leach it before you use it.

UMass uses a lower injury line for soil, not for the compost itself: soluble salts above 0.6 dS/m can injure plants and limit growth, depending on the crop’s stage and the weather. The fact sheet, last updated March 16, 2017, lists a $6 soluble-salt add-on when it is requested with a routine test. Confirm the current fee on the lab site before you order; the threshold is the part to remember. Excess salts pull water away from roots, so the plants look droughted in damp soil, and longer exposure can burn roots and leaves or kill plants. Sources include fertilizers, manures, composts, organic matter, ice-melt runoff, and salty irrigation water. Leaching, as UMass describes it for the top foot of soil, is about 6 inches of low-salt water to remove roughly half the salts, and about 12 inches of water to remove roughly 80 percent. One inch of water over 100 square feet is 62 gallons. Cover crops are the other tool they name for mopping up leftover nutrients: oats, sudangrass, buckwheat, cereal rye, and annual ryegrass, cut and removed when lush, and composted somewhere other than the bed you are trying to draw down. That biomass is nutrient removal only if you haul the tops away.

pH, maturity, and herbicides

Finished compost is usually slightly alkaline, the New England guide says, and it usually will not drive a field soil to an undesirably high pH, because the total alkalinity is modest. Two exceptions: compost that was “stabilized” with added lime, which raises alkalinity, and heavy rates on crops that want to stay acid. Scab-susceptible potatoes are the example, with a soil pH around 5.2. A heavy application can lift pH for a growing season. UMN adds that plant-based composts vary from acid to alkaline, manure-based composts are often slightly alkaline, and many Minnesota agricultural and garden soils are buffered strongly enough that a nutrient-sized compost rate may not move pH much. Blueberries, which UMN says thrive around pH 4 to 5, are a poor place to park alkaline manure compost and hope the pH stays put. If the soil report already includes a lime recommendation, follow that line (explained in Soil pH and lime: what your test is telling you) instead of counting on compost to do the liming.

Maturity is a temperature test, not a color test. The New England guide calls compost finished when the easily decomposed fraction is gone, biological activity has slowed, the pile is back to air temperature, and it does not heat up again when turned. That can take a couple of weeks or more than a year. Unfinished compost can hurt growth because the composting microbes compete with the crop for nitrogen. Spreading at least a week before seeding or transplanting is the guide’s margin if you are unsure. Immature compost from nitrogen-rich feedstocks is often high in ammonium, which can become ammonia gas and injure plants. In a field that ammonium is less often a crisis. In a greenhouse mix it is a reason to reject the material.

Herbicide carryover is the failure mode that looks like a disease. The New England guide says some broadleaf herbicides labeled for turf, pasture, and hay stay active in the manure of animals that ate treated forage, and they survive composting of treated crop residue. Vegetable growers have damaged crops with purchased manure and compost that still carried those herbicides. Ask the seller for assurance that the material is not from treated turf or hay. A nutrient test will not show this. If tomatoes and beans cup and twist after a compost addition and the soil test looks ordinary, herbicide residue belongs on the list of questions for the supplier and the county office.

Lawns and the clock for the next test

Penn State’s establishment guide allows compost as a 1- to 2-inch layer worked 4 to 6 inches into a new lawn, in stages if you need more than 2 inches, and it says poor-quality compost should not be used. Missouri’s lawn publication estimates a one-inch covering at about two cubic yards for a 1,000-square-foot area, blended through the upper 4 to 6 inches, and it wants that material low in soluble salts and free of pathogens and weed seed. Both of those rates are for establishment on soil that still needs organic matter. Neither one overrides a phosphorus result that is already high. Cornell’s lawn-establishment sheet warns that compost at planting can push phosphorus past what the grass needs and into a range that sheet treats as a water-quality concern. Read the lawn report before you order a truckload. Soil testing before you start a new lawn walks through that timing.

The New England guide’s check on whether the compost did what you hoped is another soil test, taken 6 to 8 weeks after spreading so the compost and the soil have equilibrated. Testing the next morning measures the granules, not the bed. UMass, for soils that are already excessive, wants the follow-up at the end of the season and then yearly, with no compost in between until a report asks for it. If you are also tracking organic matter as a soil-health number rather than as a fertilizer credit, the separate discussion is in Organic matter and soil texture tests.

Moisture changes the spreading job even when the chemistry is acceptable. UMN says compost wetter than about 60 percent moisture is hard to spread, and compost drier than about 40 percent can be dusty. Total solids plus moisture equal 100 percent. If your aim is organic matter rather than a nutrient dump, a higher-solids compost delivers more organic matter per ton than a load that is mostly water. UMN also notes that organic carbon is about half of the organic matter in compost, so a report of 30 percent organic carbon is about 60 percent organic matter, with the rest made up of soil particles, minerals, and dissolved nutrients.

No single extension sheet tells every garden to add an inch of compost every spring. The sequence these labs actually publish is: test the soil, test the compost if you can, skip the compost when phosphorus or salts are already high, use the carbon-to-nitrogen note from the lab that ran the compost, and retest on the interval that matches the problem you are correcting. County offices and the public labs in the state directory can say whether they analyze compost as compost. Sending a compost sample in on a field-soil form is the mistake the New England guide tells you not to make.

Sources

  1. Compost | New England Vegetable Management Guide
  2. Interpreting your compost report | UMN Extension
  3. Corrective Measures and Management of Over-Fertilized Soils | UMass Soil and Plant Nutrient Testing Laboratory
  4. Lawn Establishment | Penn State Extension
  5. Soil Testing for Lawns (G6954) | University of Missouri Extension
  6. Getting the most out of your soil test report for lawn establishment | Cornell CALS (archived copy)

Free checklist · PDF

Soil Sampling Checklist

How to collect a soil sample your extension lab can actually use, and how to read the report when it comes back.

Free. We email you the download link, plus an occasional plain-English guide. Unsubscribe any time. We never sell your email. Privacy