Lead and urban garden soil tests

Last updated

Match an urban lot’s history to a contaminant test (lead, arsenic, cadmium, zinc, or PAHs) and separate that panel from an ordinary fertility soil test.

A routine garden analysis answers whether the bed is acid and whether phosphorus or potassium is short. It does not, by itself, answer whether an old city lot holds lead, arsenic, cadmium, zinc, or polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. EPA’s fact sheet Growing Gardens in Urban Soils (EPA/542/F-10/011) says those five are commonly found in urban soil, with still other chemicals near former commercial or industrial sites. If you only mail a fertility form, you can get a careful lime recommendation for ground you should not be growing food in. The sampling steps for a lead-focused test are in Testing garden soil for lead and other metals. This page is about choosing the analyte from the lot’s past, and about what a number does and does not authorize.

Start with the former use, then pick the chemical

EPA’s table ties common sources to specific contaminants. Paint from before 1978, plus old houses, mining, leather tanning, landfills, and aircraft-parts manufacturing, points to lead. Soil beside heavily used roads, especially roads built before leaded gasoline was phased out, points to lead, zinc, and PAHs. Lumber-treatment sites point to arsenic, chromium, and copper. Burning waste and landfill fires point to PAHs and dioxins. Manure from animals whose feed included copper and zinc salts can raise those two metals. Coal ash from power plants and landfills is associated with molybdenum and sulfur. Sewage sludge and treatment-plant residuals are associated with cadmium, copper, zinc, lead, and persistent bioaccumulative toxics. Petroleum spills at gas stations and around storage tanks are associated with PAHs, benzene, toluene, xylene, and ethylbenzene. Orchards and other heavy pesticide use are associated with lead, arsenic, mercury, chlordane, and other chlorinated pesticides. Dry cleaners are associated with Stoddard solvent and tetrachloroethene. Metal-finishing shops are associated with metals and cyanides.

That list is a reason to ask a lab for a targeted panel, not a reason to assume every urban backyard fails all of it. A house built in 1920 with peeling trim is a lead question. A backyard that was a pear orchard is a lead-and-arsenic question. A lot behind a former dry cleaner is a solvent question that a metals-only package will miss. Write down what you know (year of the building, distance to a major road, any fill of unknown origin, a garage, a railroad spur, a factory) and hand that note to the lab or the county office before you choose a package. If you do not know the history, say so. Unknown fill is its own reason to test, because you cannot see the previous site in the soil color.

Background concentrations also shift with geology. EPA says some regions naturally run higher for certain elements, and it points gardeners to a local extension service or the state environmental agency for local background, plus USGS work on national soil geochemistry. A result that looks high next to a national pamphlet can be ordinary for your county, or the reverse. Ask someone who interprets that state’s data before you treat a single number as a verdict.

EPA’s Envirofacts database, which includes the Toxics Release Inventory, lets you search reported releases by ZIP code, address, or county. A hit near your block means a facility reported a release. It does not measure the soil in your bed. Use it as a clue about what to request, then confirm with samples.

A vacant commercial lot is a bigger process than a home bed

For land that used to be industrial or commercial, EPA describes two formal studies. A Phase I assessment is a trained review of historical uses, interviews, and a site walk to judge whether contamination is plausible and what kind. If that review says yes, a Phase II assessment samples and maps the affected areas. Local or state environmental agencies are the contact for how those studies work. Some local governments can do them or have staff who can. Federal brownfields grants, which EPA defines around property where reuse is complicated by contamination, go to government entities. A neighborhood garden on a former plating shop should be talking to the city and the state environmental office before anyone orders a mail-in fertility kit.

EPA is also clear that its soil screening levels were built for Superfund decisions (whether a pathway such as ingestion, skin contact, or breathing dust needs more investigation) and that the agency does not publish screening levels written for gardening. Some states borrow residential screening levels for gardens, or they set a number for a particular site. A residential screening level is not a promise that food grown there is fine, and failing to exceed one is not a substitute for the gardening practices below. If a report cites a screening level you do not recognize, ask the lab or the state environmental agency which scenario that number assumed.

The main contact is soil in the mouth and on the leaves

EPA describes two ways people meet these contaminants while gardening. The first is the soil-to-person path: contaminated soil gets into the mouth, or dust is breathed. Children do this through hand-to-mouth play. Adults do it by eating unwashed produce that still carries soil. Skin contact matters for some chemicals, including PAHs, chromium, and trichloroethylene. The soil-to-plant-to-person path is real but, in EPA’s summary of the research, a smaller risk than swallowing soil. Uptake depends on the plant and on pH and organic matter. Root vegetables have more potential to accumulate contaminants because the part you eat formed in the soil. Washing under running water cuts the soil you would otherwise eat with the food.

Phytoremediation (hoping a plant will mine the metal out) does not work for lead. EPA says lead is generally not available for plant uptake, so planting a “lead-removing” crop and hauling it away will not clean the bed. Amendments that bind lead, and physical separation from the soil, are the approaches the fact sheet actually supports. Do not compost the tops of a plant you grew in order to extract metals and then spread that compost on a food bed.

Fruiting crops are the better fit when the ground is only mildly contaminated. EPA names tomatoes, squash, apples, pears, and berries as examples of plants whose edible portion is a fruit. Carrots, potatoes, and onions are the poorer fit, because you eat the part that touched the soil. Cabbage, lettuce, and collards collect dust and splash on their outer leaves, so those leaves should be discarded before washing, especially the ones nearest the ground. This is exposure reduction, not a claim that any crop is lead-free.

Beds, fabric, and clean fill

EPA calls raised beds and containers the most common way to cut contact, because the clean mix is a physical barrier. The construction details in the fact sheet are specific. Lay landscape fabric on the existing ground before you add clean soil and organic matter, so roots are less likely to grow down into the old soil. For a permanent frame, ask for lumber that was not pressure-treated. Treated wood is on the same fact sheet’s source list for arsenic, chromium, and copper. Dust and splash from paths can still land in the bed, so cover walkways with mulch, grass, or another groundcover.

If you remove soil and replace it, ask the supplier for evidence that the replacement was tested and is low in the contaminants you are worried about. “Clean fill” on an invoice is not a lab report. Adding a thick organic layer can also separate people from contaminated surface soil, and EPA says amendments have been used to bind some contaminants so they move less. The fact sheet’s dilution guidance (organic amendments up to a 50:50 mix by volume) is about lowering contaminant concentration and improving tilth on mildly contaminated ground. It is not permission to ignore a fertility test. Compost and manure still carry nutrients. If a separate nutrient test is already excessive, see Using compost after you read a soil test before you follow a high compost rate.

EPA’s healthy-gardening page adds day-to-day habits that apply while you wait for results and after you have them: gloves, handwashing, washing toys and tools, storing tools outside living space, shoes off at the door, doormats, and regular floor cleaning. Keep children and pets out of the garden while the lead level is unknown. Locate plantings away from old painted buildings and heavily trafficked roads. Peel carrots, beets, turnips, and radishes. Wash fruit and vegetables. Those steps reduce exposure. They do not erase a high test.

How EPA sorts lead results for food gardens

EPA’s healthy-gardening page states that milligrams per kilogram and parts per million are the same quantity in soil. It then sorts gardening choices by the lead result:

  • Approaching 200 ppm: use the hygiene and washing practices, and put deep-rooted food plants in raised beds. Root vegetables and shallow-rooted plants may stay in the existing soil under those practices. Limit gardening if you are pregnant or nursing.
  • 200 to 400 ppm: the existing soil needs changes. Raised beds of clean soil plus compost or manure, mulch or groundcover on bare soil, and peeling root vegetables. Root crops and shallow-rooted food plants go in raised beds of clean soil. Deep-rooted food plants are not recommended even in raised beds, unless the plant is in a container.
  • Over 400 ppm: do not use the existing soil for food. Shallow-rooted plants only, in a raised bed with at least 16 inches of clean soil over garden fabric, or in containers. No root vegetables except in a container. No deep-rooted food plants except in a container. Cover bare soil or keep it damp, and add clean soil and organic matter to the beds or containers each year.

EPA also says to adjust pH toward near neutral, about 6.5 to 7.5, to limit lead uptake into plants, and to check with a university soil lab or extension office before you add other amendments. Children, and women who are pregnant or breastfeeding, are more sensitive to lead. EPA notes that a nutritious diet is associated with lower lead absorption in children; that is a health statement from EPA, not a soil treatment, and a high soil test is still a reason to talk with a clinician or your local health department if a child plays in the dirt. This page cannot tell you whether a person has been exposed. A blood test ordered by a clinician is the medical tool. Your local health department may be able to tell you about soil lead testing or a screening event. EPA also lists soilSHOP events where you can bring garden soil for a contaminant screen that includes lead. University and extension labs are the other route; find the public lab on the state list and ask whether the package reports total lead or only a weaker extract.

What not to conclude

A fertility report with a pleasant pH does not clear a lot for lead or PAHs. A single composite from the middle of the yard can miss the drip line under old siding, which is often the hotter spot for paint chips. A residential screening level from a cleanup program is not EPA’s gardening chart, and EPA’s gardening chart is not a medical clearance. If the history includes a dry cleaner, a gas station, or a plating shop, a lead-only test is the wrong order form. Ask the lab which method it will run, keep the chain of results, and if the numbers are high enough that you are deciding whether a community garden should open, bring the state environmental agency in rather than improvising a remedy from a forum.

Gardening on city land can still be a reasonable plan. EPA’s fact sheet says the possibility of contamination should not, by itself, stop the planning, provided you identify what is there and separate people and food crops from it. The work is the history, the right analysis, and a barrier you can see (fabric, clean tested soil, covered paths) not a thicker layer of the soil you have not tested.

Sources

  1. Growing Gardens in Urban Soils (EPA/542/F-10/011) | US EPA
  2. Healthy Gardening Practices to Reduce Exposure to Lead-Contaminated Soil | US EPA

Free checklist · PDF

Soil Sampling Checklist

How to collect a soil sample your extension lab can actually use, and how to read the report when it comes back.

Free. We email you the download link, plus an occasional plain-English guide. Unsubscribe any time. We never sell your email. Privacy